5:23 Doncaster
A modest Class 5 handicap over 1m2f43y at Doncaster on good to firm ground brings together six three-year-olds with relatively limited experience between them. The KTB Fit scores reflect a largely ordinary bunch, headed by Shadow Brigade on 54, with the next three clustered between 47 and 45, suggesting a race that may not take much winning if one can find a bit of improvement. First-time headgear on two runners and several stepping up or down in trip or class adds a layer of uncertainty to proceedings.
How the race shapes up
With the pace shape rated unclear and low confidence, there is not enough evidence to be definitive about how the race will unfold. Alterity is the only confirmed front-runner and could take them along, while Shadow Brigade is typically held up and will look to come from off the pace. The key question is whether the modest performers can produce enough to make the race a true test or whether it will turn into something of a sprint for the line in the straight.
The KTB Fit ranking
- 1Shadow Brigade KTB Selection54/100Modest performer who has shown little sign of progress in five starts and was well held again last time.
- 2Alterity47/100Modest performer with a solid recent record of two placed efforts from his last three starts.
- 3Saxophonist45/100Modest performer who has shown consistent placed form this year without progressing.
- 4Zarco45/100Modest performer who showed ordinary form in three runs last season, finishing no closer than fifth.
- 5Brighlee41/100Modest performer who has shown bits of ability but remains winless after seven starts.
- 6Time Twister36/100Limited performer who has failed to make the frame in five starts and looks up against it again from a modest ratings base.
The contenders
Shadow Brigade KTB Fit 54/100
Shadow Brigade is a modest performer who has shown little sign of progress in five starts and was well held again last time out. He is trying the trip for only the second time and first-time headgear is now fitted. Trainer George Scott holds a solid 15% strike rate at Doncaster while Liam Wright has an excellent 18% record at the track from limited rides. Usually held up, he produces his effort late and will be looking to come from off the pace in a race where the shape is not easy to read. The combination of the yard's course record, the jockey's track strike rate and the addition of headgear gives him a chance to show something more meaningful here.
Alterity KTB Fit 47/100
Alterity is a modest performer with a solid recent record of two placed efforts from his last three starts. He steps up to 1m2f for the first time today which asks a fresh question of him. Trainer Charlie Johnston has an 8% strike rate from 106 runs at Doncaster while jockey David Egan fares better with 16% from 188 rides. Tending to make the running or race prominently, he could set the pace in a field where overall run-style evidence is limited. His placed form gives him a solid platform but the longer trip remains the big unknown.
Saxophonist KTB Fit 45/100
Saxophonist is a modest performer who has shown consistent placed form this year without progressing. He ran a respectable third over course and distance on his most recent start but that effort fits the overall pattern of him finding a bit more needed at this level. Trainer David O'Meara has a modest 9% strike rate at Doncaster while Callum Rodriguez fares a little better with 14%. With two runs on good to firm and a placed effort over C&D already on his record, conditions look suitable enough. He will need to improve on his placed efforts to take this.
Zarco KTB Fit 45/100
Zarco is a modest performer who showed ordinary form in three runs last season, finishing no closer than fifth. He steps up in trip today for a yard that has a solid 20% strike rate at Doncaster, though the jockey's 11% record from 282 rides here is more average. Dropping in class and with only three career starts he remains lightly raced and not fully exposed. Unproven on good to firm ground, that adds another layer of guesswork. His yard's course record offers some hope that he can find the necessary improvement.
The rest of the field
BrighleeKTB Fit 41/100
Brighlee is a modest performer who has shown bits of ability but remains winless after seven starts. Has been placed at this trip and is well drawn in stall one, though first-time headgear is now needed to spark improvement. The trainer has a modest record at Doncaster while the jockey is still seeking a first winner here.
Time TwisterKTB Fit 36/100
Time Twister is a limited performer who has failed to make the frame in five starts and looks up against it again from a modest ratings base. The yard's modest record at Doncaster offers little encouragement, nor does the jockey's similar strike rate here. Trip remains a question as the horse was beaten on the only attempt at this distance.
KTB verdict
Shadow Brigade is the KTB Selection and represents the strongest overall profile in a modest event. His yard's healthy 15% strike rate at Doncaster combined with Liam Wright's excellent 18% record at the track from limited rides provides a positive backdrop, while the first-time headgear could help unlock more from a horse who has been held up in his races so far. The main dangers are likely to come from Alterity, who brings solid recent placed form and could make the running, and Saxophonist, who has already shown placed form over course and distance. Zarco cannot be entirely dismissed as a lightly raced sort dropping in class for a yard that fares well here.
KTB Selection Shadow Brigade
This is the narrative read of the 5:23 Doncaster. For the live card — runner-by-runner stats, the full Fit Score breakdown and current odds — see the Doncaster racecard. New here? How KTB works explains the Fit Score and why we publish both.
Questions about this race
Which horse is trying the longest trip for the first time?
Alterity steps up to 1m2f for the first time today.
Who is wearing first-time headgear in this race?
Shadow Brigade and Brighlee are both fitted with first-time headgear.
Which runner has previous course and distance form at Doncaster?
Saxophonist ran a respectable third over course and distance on his most recent start.
Which horse is dropping in class?
Zarco is dropping in class.
What is the trainer and jockey combined strike rate for the yard of Time Twister?
Michael & David Easterby and Joanna Mason have a combined record of 108/1013 (11%) with an A/E of 0.84.
18+. Analysis and entertainment only — no guarantee of profit. KTB race previews are published for interest and are not betting advice. Only ever stake what you can comfortably afford to lose, and set your own limits. Free, confidential help: the National Gambling Helpline on 0808 8020 133 (GamCare.org.uk); in Ireland, the GamblingCare.ie helpline on 1800 936 725. Self-exclude at any time via GAMSTOP.
More from Kickthebookies