Skip to content
Horse profile

Chicago Critic (GB)

5yo gelding · Trainer J P Murtagh · Owner Sam Mencoff Tony Smurfit
by Night Of Thunder (IRE) out of Criticism (GB) (Machiavellian)
17 runs · 10 courses · from Sep 2023
As at 25 Oct 2026 · KTB archive: GB, Ireland & France · 2005–present, updated daily
3 wins · Leopardstown & Naas Last run 6 Aug 2026 · 6th of 8 Last raced off OR 104
KTB Profile

Chicago Critic is 3 from 17 on turf with all wins at 1m – 1m1f. He gained a Listed success in the Porsche In Support Of Breast Cancer Ireland Amethyst Stakes at Leopardstown in May 2025 off an official rating of 106 and had earlier scored in a handicap at Naas and a maiden at the same track. The gelding, by Night Of Thunder out of Criticism, is usually held up. His last run, at Leopardstown in Aug 2026, was a 6 of 8 finish in the Bahrain Turf Club Desmond Stakes off an official rating of 104.

Based on 17 archived runs · run-style from 10 commented runs since Oct 2024 · updated 25 Oct 2026
KTB at a glance Typically held up
Official rating104↓ 6lb off peak
104 90–110

KTB Speed and Rating

KTB Speed

Best recent Speed 112 the best of the last 3 graded (A or B) runs · Epsom Downs, 6 Jun 2026

How fast the horse ran, as points against the day-corrected standard time for its course and distance: 100 is the median GB Class 4 handicap winner on that code; one point is 0.1% of the standard time. A, B or C is how much the day's card could tell us, not how good the run was. What this means →

Flat 16 figures · best 116A · median 95.5
GoingRunsBestMedianSince 25 Oct 2025
Good8116A103.53 runs · 104 / 103
Good to Soft4112A88.51 run · —
Heavy389C86—
Good to Firm1———
DistanceRunsBestMedianSince 25 Oct 2025
6f – 7f9112A843 runs · 112 / 104
1m – 1m1f7116A981 run · —

Of 17 runs looked at, 1 has no figure: not enough races on the card to set the day (under 4) (1).

KTB Speed v1 · batch 15 Sep 2026 · GB & Irish racing only · 16 figures from 17 runs · as at 3 Oct 2026 · a record, not a forecast

KTB Rating

Best recent KTB Rating 96A the best of the last 3 rated runs · Epsom Downs, 6 Jun 2026 Official rating 104 at the last run, 6 Aug 2026

What the horse achieved in each race, in pounds on the official-rating scale, from the weight carried, the lengths beaten and the race's own level solved across the archive — never the market, never the official rating as a starting point. The headline is the best of the horse's last three rated runs on that code. A, B or C on a run is how much known form was in that race. What this means →

Flat 17 figures · best 112A · median 92
GoingRunsBestMedianSince 25 Oct 2025
Good8102B923 runs · 92 / 92
Good to Soft496A921 run · —
Heavy3101A85—
Soft1———
Good to Firm1———
DistanceRunsBestMedianSince 25 Oct 2025
6f – 7f10112A913 runs · 96 / 92
1m – 1m1f7102B991 run · —

KTB Rating v1 · batch 3 Oct 2026 · GB & Irish racing only · 17 figures from 17 runs · as at 4 Oct 2026 · a record, not a forecast

Both figures are KTB's own, computed from the archive; no vendor rating enters either. Every run's figure is on its form line below with its grade. Grades measure how much the archive could see, never the merit of the run.

Run style from 10 analysed runs since Oct 2024

  • Held up 6 (60%) · 1 win
  • Mid-division 3 (30%) · 0 wins
  • Prominent 1 (10%) · 0 wins

Pedigree intelligence

Sire

Progeny in our archive have won 16.3% of 5,076 runs since Jan 2008 (562 horses).

Weakest over 1m5f – 2m (all codes): 7% from 157.

GoingRunsWinsSRvs sireThis horse
Firm4250%+33.7—
Good to Firm83115418.5%+2.20 from 1
Good1,22019916.3%02 from 8
Good to Soft5809215.9%−0.40 from 4
Soft70312017.1%+0.80 from 1
Heavy2153616.7%+0.41 from 3
Standard (AW)1,52322414.7%−1.6—
Distance (all codes)RunsWinsSRvs sireThis horse
Under 6f3836015.7%−0.6—
6f – 7f2,11537217.6%+1.30 from 10
1m – 1m1f1,36120615.1%−1.23 from 7
1m2f – 1m4f1,00217217.2%+0.9—
1m5f – 2m157117%−9.3—
2m1f – 2m4f47510.6%−5.7—
2m5f – 3m9111.1%−5.2—
Over 3m200%−16.3—

Flat and jumps together (all codes) · since Jan 2008 · as at 25 Oct 2026 · rows under 30 runs muted · win % is the measure, a record not a forecast

Dam
Criticism (GB) (Machiavellian)

6 siblings in the archive, 1 winner — best of them Belabour (GB) (2 wins).

The wins came over 1m4f–1m4½f; the highest grade won is Class 5 (Belabour (GB)).

ProduceRunsWinsWin tripsBest grade
Belabour (GB)2421m4f–1m4½fClass 5
Diplomatic Force (USA)50——
Book Review (GB)30——
Magical Touch (GB)50——
Rival Poet (USA)10——
Javana (GB)10——

Record by conditions

GoingRunsWinsSR£1
Good 8 2 25% +15.00
Good to Soft 4 0 0% −4.00
Heavy 3 1 33% +0.25
Soft 1 0 0% −1.00
Good to Firm 1 0 0% −1.00

ClassRunsWinsSR£1
Class 1 5 0 0% −5.00

CourseRunsWinsSR£1
Leopardstown 4 1 25% +11.00
Naas 4 2 50% +7.25
Curragh 2 0 0% −2.00
Leopardstown (IRE) 1 0 0% −1.00
York 1 0 0% −1.00
Epsom Downs 1 0 0% −1.00
Cork 1 0 0% −1.00
Tipperary 1 0 0% −1.00
Goodwood 1 0 0% −1.00
Ascot 1 0 0% −1.00

DistanceRunsWinsSR£1
6f – 7f 10 0 0% −10.00
1m – 1m1f 7 3 43% +19.25

JockeyRunsWinsSR£1
Ben Coen 13 3 23% +13.25
Seamie Heffernan 3 0 0% −3.00
Oisin Orr 1 0 0% −1.00

HeadgearRunsWinsSR£1
None 14 3 21% +12.25
Cheekpieces 2 0 0% −2.00
Blinkers 1 0 0% −1.00

SeasonRunsWinsSR£1
2026 4 0 0% −4.00
2025 5 1 20% +10.00
2024 6 1 17% +2.00
2023 2 1 50% +1.25

Splits include every sample, however small — muted rows are under 3 runs. A one-from-one record is a fact, not a trend: read the Runs column before the strike rate.

Form

DateCourseRace PosBtn Wgt ORSpdKTB Jockey SP
2026 · 4 runs
06 Aug 26+40d Leopardstown (IRE) Bahrain Turf Club Desmond Stakes (Group 3) Class 1 · 8f · Good · 8 ran Held up towards the back - driven into contention around 2f out to sit 5th with a furlong left - held no more late 6/8 1¾ 9-9 104103A86A Ben Coen 8/1
27 Jun 26+21d York Al Basti Equiworld Dubai Criterion Stakes (Group 3) Class 1 · 7f · Good · 6 ran Held up at the back - closing gradually with 2f left before finding nothing on the front pack a furlong out - weakened close home to finish fourth 4/6 2 9-8 106104A92B Oisin Orr 10/1
06 Jun 26+14d Epsom Downs Betfred Tattenham Corner Stakes (Group 3) Class 1 · 7f · Good To Soft · 8 ran Held up in the pack - pushed along inside final furlong - kept going late but never in contention - finished fourth 4/8 2¼ 9-2 106112A96A Ben Coen 25/1
23 May 26+252d Curragh Weatherbys Ireland Greenlands Stakes (Group 2) 6f · Good · 10 ran Held up at the back - still 7th at halfway - driven approaching 2f out but unable to make headway from over 1f out and beaten into 8th 8/10 1¾ 9-5 10799A92A Ben Coen 14/1
2025 · 5 runs
13 Sep 25+37d Leopardstown TonyBet Solonaway Stakes (Group 2) 8f · Good To Yielding · 9 ran Held up towards the back - improved into 4th and asked for effort 2f out - shared 2nd 1 1/2f out then 3rd approaching final furlong - unable to find more late and finished 7th 7/9 1 9-10 10893A94A Seamie Heffernan 15/2
07 Aug 25+18d Leopardstown Bahrain Turf Club Desmond Stakes (Group 3) 8f · Good · 6 ran Settled at the back early - still behind the pack at halfway - moved into 4th and edged right with 2f left - into 4th a furlong out under pressure - finished strongly to grab 3rd near the line 3/6 ½ 9-9 110116A102B Seamie Heffernan 8/1
20 Jul 25+70d Curragh Romanised Minstrel Stakes (Group 2) 7f · Good To Yielding · 10 ran Drifted slightly left leaving the stalls - settled in the pack - urged forward with over 2f left - lost momentum from a furlong out to finish ninth 9/10 1 9-10 11084A86A Ben Coen 11/1
11 May 25+35d Leopardstown Porsche In Support Of Breast Cancer Ireland Amethyst Stakes (Listed) 8f · Good · 6 ran Settled towards the back early - still there over 3f out in 6th - made ground 1 1/2f out - hit the front a furlong out - powered clear to win 1/6 9-9 10698A99B Ben Coen 14/1
06 Apr 25+182d Cork Irish Stallion Farms EBF Cork Stakes (Listed) 6f · Good · 8 ran Settled with the pack early - began to feel the strain over 2f out and dropped away 1½f out - trailed off in the closing stages 7/8 ¾ 9-9 107108A82A Ben Coen 5/1
2024 · 6 runs
06 Oct 24+68d Tipperary Coolmore Sioux Nation Concorde Stakes (Listed) 7.5f · Soft · 14 ran Sat behind the front group early - third at halfway - urged on turning for home - driven with a furlong left - briefly up to second inside the final 100 yards but faded to finish fourth 4/14 hd 9-5 109—101A Seamie Heffernan 3/1
30 Jul 24+38d Goodwood HKJC World Pool Lennox Stakes (Group 2) Class 1 · 7f · Good · 8 ran 7/8 shd 8-13 10970A85A Ben Coen 12/1
22 Jun 24+34d Ascot Jersey Stakes (Group 3) Class 1 · 7f · Good To Firm · 19 ran 3/19 1 9-3 9784C112A Ben Coen 80/1
19 May 24+42d Naas Royal Ascot Trials At Naas Handicap 8f · Good · 10 ran 1/10 9-9 90112A101A Ben Coen 7/1
07 Apr 24+14d Leopardstown Ballylinch Stud 'Red Rocks' Stakes (Group 3) 7f · Heavy · 8 ran 6/8 4 9-5 9383A74A Ben Coen 16/1
24 Mar 24+162d Naas TRM Equine Nutrition Race 8f · Heavy · 5 ran 3/5 4¼ 9-9 —89C85B Ben Coen 4/1
2023 · 2 runs
14 Oct 23+30d Naas Irish Stallion Farms EBF Maiden 8f · Soft To Heavy · 12 ran 1/12 9-7 —86A101A Ben Coen 9/4
14 Sep 23 Naas Irish Stallion Farms EBF Maiden 7f · Good To Yielding · 9 ran 3/9 ½ 9-7 —61A90A Ben Coen 25/1

Quick answers

How many races has Chicago Critic won?
Chicago Critic (GB) won 3 of 17 archived starts between 2023 and 2026, a strike rate of 17.6%. Placed 5 times in total (29.4% of starts).
Who trains Chicago Critic?
Chicago Critic (GB) is trained by J P Murtagh, who saddled the horse on its most recent run on 6 August 2026.
Who is Chicago Critic's sire?
Chicago Critic (GB) is by Night Of Thunder (IRE) out of Criticism (GB), whose sire is Machiavellian.
What going does Chicago Critic prefer?
Chicago Critic (GB) has the best record on heavy going: 1 win from 3 starts (33.3%). Only going bands with at least three archived starts are read, so this is a direction rather than a settled preference.
What is Chicago Critic's official rating?
The most recent official rating on record is 104, from the run on 6 August 2026. The highest on record is 110.
What is Chicago Critic's sire's record?
Night Of Thunder (IRE)'s progeny in our archive have won 16.3% of 5,076 runs since Jan 2008 (562 horses), Flat and jumps together. Weakest over 1m5f – 2m (all codes): 7% from 157.
Who are Chicago Critic's siblings?
Out of Criticism (GB), Chicago Critic (GB) has 6 other produce in our archive, 1 of them a winner. Most wins: Belabour (GB) (2). Highest grade won: Class 5 (Belabour (GB)). The wins came over 1m4f–1m4½f. As at Oct 2026.

Record shown from September 2023. Our archive holds racing in Great Britain, Ireland and France from January 2005. Runs in other countries are not in it, and earlier runs are not available from our data provider. In-running comments are available from 2024 onward.